Celebrating Over 30 Years of Goodness

From Key West to Nashville

Shop Now

Buy Now

Two Iconic Cities

🌴 Key West, Florida

Two locations on world famous Duval Street and one on historic Greene Street

🎸 Nashville, Tennessee

Located just off Broadway on 2nd Avenue North

What's In Store

Made fresh. Made here. Every single day.

Half-Pound Cookies

Half-Pound Cookies

Fresh dough made from scratch daily. One bite is all it takes.

Marble Slab Fudge

Marble Slab Fudge

Cooked in a copper kettle, poured on a 500 lb marble slab.

Coconut Macaroons

Coconut Macaroons

Delicate, chewy, and delicious — regular or chocolate dipped.

Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Homemade graham cracker crust and chocolate-dipped options.

Ice Cream

Ice Cream

Creamy, delicious ice cream — the perfect treat any time of day.

Special Orders & Events

Weddings, Birthdays, or whatever reason you want to celebrate. We are committed to baking it perfect.

Inquire Now
Special Events Special Events

Follow @cookieboyyy on TikTok

Fresh content baked daily

Watch our latest videos on TikTok

View @cookieboyyy
Duval Street Baking Mattheessen Family

Unwrap Our Story

It's not just about the cookies; it's about family

Our Story

Your Cart

Your cart is empty